Irwin, Julia F.
Catastrophic Diplomacy: US Foreign Disaster Assistance in the American Century
UNC Press (Chapel Hill)
2024
OUR SYNOPSIS: Julia F. Irwin illuminates the role of foreign assistance for sudden, so-called “natural” disasters as an important tool of American foreign policy, from the early twentieth century through to the 1970s. She argues, “It functioned as a means of projecting American power and influence globally and as a vehicle for preserving order and control abroad.” (2) Focusing on the State Department, the Armed Forces, and voluntary organizations such as the American Red Cross, she sheds light on their collaborative and inherently political humanitarian responses. She also emphasizes the federal government’s reliance on state-private partnerships for disaster assistance, blurring distinctions between state and non-state actors. These operations also tend to be bilateral rather than involving multiple nations, thus strengthening to potential for foreign policy agendas to dictate humanitarian efforts. Starting especially with the presidency of Theodore Roosevelt, she shows that disaster assistance willingness developed out of an increasingly interventionist and imperial overall foreign policy. Extensive case studies greatly strengthen these arguments through clear examples.
BIG QUESTIONS:
What are some primary foreign policy motives that drove twentieth-century American international disaster assistance?
What are the causes and implications of the prevalence of state-private partnerships for disaster aid?
FEATURE QUOTES:
“Tracing the history of US foreign disaster assistance from the early twentieth century through the mid-1970s, Catastrophic Diplomacy recovers the origins of this humanitarian practice and the complex motivations that lay behind it.” (2)
“American efforts to aid disaster survivors, in short, routinely coexisted with attempts to police, coerce, and govern them.” (11)
PRIMARY SOURCES:
American Red Cross, “RED CROSS SOCIETIES AID VIETNAMESE FLOOD VICTIMS,” c. 1960, National Archives at Boston (Waltham, MA), Collection ANRC: Records of the American National Red Cross, File Unit: Foreign Disasters, NAID: 117700077, https://s3.amazonaws.com/NARAprodstorage/lz/boston/rg-ANRC/74236257/117700077/117700077_049.jpg.
BALTIMORE CONNECTIONS:
N/A